Buy fountain pens with confidence

A moderated marketplace for collectors and enthusiasts. Quality listings, passionate buyers, and bad actors removed.

Three layers of protection

Problems are rare here

We moderate heavily and ban bad actors before they can cause trouble. Look for trust badges like Verified Artisan and Verified Business on seller profiles.

Fast refunds while we hold payment

We secure your funds until your pen ships, or longer for newer sellers, so we can often refund quickly.

PayPal, and us behind PayPal

PayPal Buyer Protection covers your purchase. If PayPal treats you unfairly, we'll help make it right, out of our own pocket if needed.

Find a pen, ask or negotiate, and check out with PayPal.

Example listing photo: a Waterman Patrician
  1. 1

    Find a pen

    Browse the fountain pen community. Heart the ones you like, and follow sellers you want to hear from.

  2. 2

    Ask or negotiate

    Ask a question on the listing, request a shipping quote, or make an offer. You can keep a message private if you need to share an address. When you make an offer, you authorize payment through PayPal.

  3. 3

    Check out with PayPal

    Buy Now at the listed price, or pay if your offer is accepted. Checkout is a simple PayPal payment.

Get the most from the marketplace.

Heart the pens you love

Save them and we'll tell you if the price drops.

Get new-listing alerts

Hear first when a pen matching what you collect is listed.

Set up listing alerts

Talk to sellers

Ask a question, request a shipping quote, or make an offer.

Follow sellers you like

Get notified about their new listings and sales.

No surprises at checkout.

A small 5% community fee is how we pay our bills, and it's built into the price.
We don't charge sellers anything.

Built by people who know marketplaces.

Our founding team came from Etsy, with decades of marketplace experience between us. We build and run Gathermark ourselves, so when you ask for a feature or report a problem, you're talking to the people who make it. Read our story →

Buying questions

What are the different ways I can purchase an item?

You have two options for purchasing:

  • Buy Now: Purchase an item immediately at its listed price.
  • Make an Offer: Propose a different price to the seller. If they accept, the transaction completes automatically.
What is the 5% "Community Fee"?
This is a fee paid by the buyer on every purchase, set at 5% of the item's price, inclusive of any shipping costs. This fee is Gathermark's primary source of revenue and is used to fund the platform's safety features (like holding payments), provide customer support, and reward the community moderators who help keep the markets safe and relevant.
How does making an offer work?
When you make an offer, you authorize the payment through PayPal at the same time. This is a security measure to show the seller you are serious. If your offer is accepted, the payment goes through instantly, and the item is yours. If the offer is rejected or expires, the payment authorization is canceled immediately.
How do I arrange a custom order (e.g., special shipping)?
You can ask the seller for a custom arrangement by posting a public question on the Listing Timeline. You can select the "keep private" button if you need to share your address, for example, to help determine a custom shipping quote. If the seller agrees, they can generate a special, private "buy button" directly in your conversation thread. This button, visible only to you, will contain the custom price for your unique order, allowing you to check out securely.
Why is most communication public on the "Listing Timeline"?
Gathermark uses a public "Listing Timeline" for most communication to foster transparency and build community trust. It allows all potential buyers to see the full history of an item, including questions and answers, which helps everyone make more informed decisions. For sensitive information, users have the option to make a message private to the seller.

Problem with an order? Go to Help & Contact →